|
|
|
Acculturation, Bicultural Identity and Psychiatric Morbidity in Young Turkish Patients in Germany
Dr. Vahdet GÜL, Dr. Semra KOLB
2009; 20(2): 138-143
|
|
|
| INTRODUCTION
|
Culture is an important factor in shaping of
identity . Cultural dynamics may play a significant role in appearance of
emotional and behavioral problems of an immigrant-adolescent's life.
When individuals migrate from one country to
another, it is likely that their cultural and ethnic identity will be
influenced from new experiences (Mann 2006). Ethnic minorities including
immigrants and refugees can favour either the dominant culture, or their own
minority culture, or both or neither. Various terms, like acculturation,
assimilation, alternation, multicultural and fusion models, have been used to
describe the psycho-social interactions within the trans-cultural process
(Floyd 2003, Gül et al 2008, Machleidt and Calliess 2005).
Acculturation is defined as socio-cultural
adjustment and acquisition of dominant cultural norms by members of a
non-dominant group. Acculturative stress refers to the psychological, somatic,
and social difficulties that may accompany acculturation processes. It was
suggested that acculturative stress is a fundamental psychological force in
acculturative processes (Berry 2003, Hovey et al 2006).
Acculturation is by no means a stress free
process. Mental health problems could be exacerbated by the acculturation
stress, leading to a possible conflict with the traditional culture of their
ethnic group (Kosic et al 2006, Ward & Kennedy 1994).
Many studies concerning mental health among
ethnic minorities have used the concept of acculturation, in particular Berry's acculturation
model (Berry 2003), to investigate the relationship among acculturation
strategies, acculturation stress, personal self-esteem, and collective
self-esteem.
Biculturalism means that an individual was
able to gain competence within two cultures without losing his or her cultural
identity (La Framboise
et al 1993, Vamsi et al 2007, Shuang 2007). Bicultural identity is sometimes
disguised to avoid the negative discriminations in a host community, whereby
intolerance and prejudices against other cultures prevailed. Being bicultural
may also be perceived by the immigrants as a handicap in the acculturation
process. This negative perception creates an enormous social acculturation
stress for immigrants to challenge (Ekşi & Sığınmacı 2002, Navas et al
2007).
A positive relationship between cultural
values and mental health problems was reported (Lahti et al 2003, Munir & Beardslee
2001). In certain ethnic populations, maintenance of greater cultural values
were found to be associated with: decreased self-esteem, an increased state and
trait anxiety, and depression; whereas, language and ethnic identity had a
minimal influence on the mental health (Hovey et al 2006,
Mossakowski 2001).
A survey over psychological adaptation of
Turkish adolescents was carried out in Sweden
and Norway.
It was shown to be the predictors of good adaptation were Turkish identity and
integration, whereas poor adaptation was related to marginalization and
perceived discrimination (Virta et al 2004, Vedder and Virta 2005).
Turkish experiences in Germany
Turks have been living in Germany for
over 45 years. The history of the first
Turkish immigrants in Germany
was marked by the desire to return to the country in which they were born one
day. However, time flies; before long they found themselves settled, married
and with children, in Germany.
Their children attended to German schools. They learned the language. Families
bought properties, set up own businesses and employed more people. Before long
they have formed the biggest group in the foreign population, with approx. 25
percent. From the total population of 2.4 million Turks, the number of the
naturalised persons, up to date, is estimated at around 500,000 in Germany
(Migrationsbericht 2006).
Turkish families are the most vulnerable
groups compared to others. They are under cultural, financial and psychosocial
stress to some extend. Overall, Turks
belong twice/thrice more often to the ?working poor? category than German or South European workers, partly due to lower qualification
and education levels. Turks are also significantly more at risk of being
unemployed and requiring social welfare than the latter.
It falls short to meet the cultural and
social expectations of the entire family. This leads to a tense and undesirable
milieu for the children and young adolescents for the social integration to
host German community.
It is estimated that the young Turks of the
second and third generation make up ca. 60 percent of the Turkish society in Germany. Half
of this population were born and grew up here. Unlike the first generation, the
younger generation distinguishes itself relatively by improved training and
education, a higher professional position and better linguistic levels.
Nowadays marriages between Turks and Germans
are no rarity. As the examples indicate, many youngsters from today's Turkish
generations are no longer fixed exclusively on the Turkish culture and
lifestyles. Thereby they are expected to be better integrated into the German
society and, as a result, motivation to return to the homeland of their parents
is lower.
Nevertheless, not every Turkish adolescent
manages well the splits between the German and the Turkish culture. The conflicts have originated from the
immigration situation, as for example, to be torn between two cultures under
acculturation stress (Yağdıran et al 2001, Murad et al 2004, Schmelling-Kludas
et al 2003, Gül et al 2008, Gün and Bayraktar 2008).
Little is known scientifically about
bicultural adjustment of the younger generation of Turks in European countries.
Due to the diverse cultural backgrounds and perceptions of psychiatric
disorders, access, diagnosis, and treatment are especially challenging within
the immigrant population (Uluşahin et al 1994, Bhugra 2006).
With the emergence of the concept of
bicultural identity, several acculturation inventories and scales were
developed mainly in the West. The acculturation scale which was used in this
study was originally prepared for the purposes of investigating the personal
and collective self-esteem of Latin-American immigrants in the United States.
This model distinguishes several domains of acculturation: language spoken most
of the time, language thought, ethnic identity, birthplace and the degree of
adjustment to the host community (Coronado et al. 2005).
Little research has examined Turkish
identity, cultural values, and Turkish language maintenance as predictors of
mental health in young people with Turkish origin, living in Germany. By
using an acculturation scale, the research presented examined to what extent
the individuals with Turkish background identified with German culture and with
their culture of origin, in the context of mental health.
|
| METHOD
|
This study adopts an acculturation framework
to examine the dominant language, cultural identity, birth place,
self-perceptions, and socio-cultural adaptation of young Turkish people, in
connection with mental disorders diagnosed in outpatients setting. The
acculturation scale was administered in Turkish or German languages according
to patients' preference or rather their competence in either language.
Patients: This study includes the data
gathered, between June 2007 and May 2008, by using the acculturation
questionnaire and the routine psychiatric examination from the patients with an
ICD-10 code inside of the Capital-F. The test and psychiatric exploration were
carried out simultaneously but separately by a qualified psychiatrist in an
authorised out-patient setting (psychiatric practice) under national health insurance
scheme in Germany.
According to the patients' self-assessment
the data collected were grouped as being acculturated and integrated against
being marginalised and separated. Then population statistics were made by using
descriptive statistics to evaluate the results. The results were presented in
the Table I.
Diagnostic methods
1. Acculturation Scale
A five-question acculturation scale adopted
from Coronado et al (2005) in USA
was used to study acculturation and the bicultural identity of young Turkish
people (between 18 to 30 years old), who had ties with Turkish culture. The
questionnaire were prepared in German and Turkish languages and a choice was
given to patients to choose Turkish or German languages to complete the tests
during psychiatric examination.
2. Psychiatric process
The psychiatric examination of patients
included in this study were carried out under the official guidelines of
relevant authorities in Germany and the diagnosis were made according to ICD-10
(WHO, German version ?Internationale Klassifikation psychischer Störungen,
Kapitel V, Klinisch-diagnostische Leitlinien?). Information over the age,
gender, employment, vocational training, acculturation stress, adaptation,
adjustment and family dynamics was supplemented from psychiatric exploration.
3. Statistics
The descriptive statistics were employed to
calculate statistical means and standard deviation. Furthermore, a statistical
comparison was made by using the x² (chi-square) test in two population
samples. To do this the Quick Method was used to calculate probability testing
in null hypothesis for the data in Group I and in Group II. (Swinscow
1978).
4. Exclusion criteria: Patients with an
organic disease and with an diagnostic code outside Capital-F in the ICD-10.
|
| FINDINGS
|
Age and gender distribution of the patients
included in this study are as follows: 122 male patients (55.45%, mean age:
24,34, s.d. ±3,87) and 98 female patients (44,55%, mean age: 21,88, s.d. ±
2,96) in total 220 patients (mean
age: 23,4, s.d. ± 3,49) out of consecutive 1148 patients (19,16%) at the range
of 18 to30 years old were included to this study (19,16%).
The results indicate that among 220 patients
included to this study, 154 (70%)
patients, (88 male- 57,14%, mean age:22,1 sd. ± 3,26 and 66 female- 42,85%,
mean age: 21,73 sd. ± 1,19) were found
to be relatively good adjusted (group 1), and of 66 (30%) patients (44 male-
66,6%, mean age:26,3 sd. ±3,39 and 22
female- 33,3%, mean age:25,88 sd. ±
3,41) were found to be relatively poor adjusted (group 2) to the host community
(Table I).
The results show that there were significant
differences in the two groups (p< 0.001, x²- Testing). Subjects with both
Turkish and German cultures have identified themselves as integrated to the
German life. These individuals were depicted in the first group with better
integration. A majority of the subjects in this group have the ability to use
both languages as speaking and thinking languages, whereas, Turkish is the
dominant language in the second group. The subjects in the second group pointed
out close ties with mainly Turkish language and culture (p< 0.001).
Our findings show that ?birth place' also
plays an important role in the acculturation process; more people (65%) were
born, in the first group, in Germany,
whereas the majority of subjects (82%) were born in Turkey, in the second group (p<
0,001). The findings over description of ?cultural identity' show similarly a
significant difference in two groups (p<0.02).
The findings over the ?Employment' and ?vocational
training' extrapolated from the anamnesis indicate that these were important
additional two predictors facilitating the acculturation process (p< 0.001).
The results presented in Table II showed
etiologically two distinct patterns of co-morbidity. Endogenous depression and the depression
caused by the conflicts in the family-milieu are significantly more common in
the group with better integration. Unlike, the depression triggered by the
psycho-social maladjustment is clearly more prevalent in the group with poor
integration (p< 0.01).
The obsessive-compulsive disorders were found
exclusively in the first group, while the dysthymia appears to be only in the
second group with poor integration. The figures of anxiety disorders, psychosis
and substance misuse show no big difference between the two groups.
|
| DISCUSSION
|
The results indicate that the majority of
young participants born in Germany
equally identified with both cultures; suggesting that bicultural identity is a
coping resource for young Turks living in Germany. Further, it fails to prove
a strong link between Turkish identity and better mental health. The predictors
of good adaptation were shown to be: bilingualism, bicultural identity and Germany as country of birth, whereas poor
adaptation was related to: dominance of ethnic culture and language, and being
born outside of Germany.
The present research provides firm evidence
for a bicultural identity through assessments of several domains of
acculturation: language spoken most of the time, language of thought, ethnic
identity, birthplace and the degree of adjustment to the host community. By the
good integration for the people with Turkish background is meant to live side
by side with German people without any intimidation, fear or any kind of
prejudice arising from issues on culture, ethnicity or race.
The risk of any co-occurring psychiatric
disorder was higher among individuals with high levels of total acculturation
stress and family-specific acculturation stress. These findings were generally
accounted for by associations between affective disorders and high scores on
these indicators of acculturation stress.
Nevertheless, the degree of acculturation-related family stress is
positively associated with co-occurring substance and psychiatric disorders,
particularly affective disorders. Intervention in family strain related to the
acculturation process may diminish the development of co-morbid mental
disorders.
Some studies have shown that the outcome of
many diseases, like many psychiatric conditions, vary across cultures (Gong
2007). Culture of origin and strength of ethnic identity have been reported to
account for a significant proportion in perceived physical and mental health.
Some studies support the need for considering ethnic identity as well as
country of origin in providing care for clients (Cleveland & Laroche 2007).
In agreement with previous studies, (Beiser
& Hou 2006, Gong 2007), our results show that dominant language, birth
place, employment status and bicultural identity are the most important
determining factors in emerging psychological stress in the acculturation
process. The findings further indicate that bicultural identity has no role in
the development of endogen depression. Psycho-social maladjustment depression
is more prevalent with ethnic identity.
Despite the fact that Turks have lived in Germany for
over four decades, (Migrationsbericht 2006), the gap in socio-cultural life
remains large. Still today, many young Turks feel torn between both worlds. So
naturally, the splits between the German and the Turkish culture were not
managed successfully by every Turkish adolescent (Ilkilic 2002). This inner
conflict feeling often finds its expression in the metaphor: ?sitting between
two chairs ?, on one hand, the traditional world of the parents with stronger
own cultural values, on the other hand, Germans' liberal life which invites a
greater sense of individuality, freedom and permissiveness. This puts
(especially) young Turks under enormous psychological pressure (Zielke-Nadkarni
2003, Virta 2004, Pette et al 2004, Vedder and Virta 2005). Nevertheless, a vital step
in bridging this gap would be an equal partnership in the new socio-cultural
life, i.e. moving away from assumptions of the linear model of cultural
acquisition and assimilation.
Many young Turks, from the second or third
generations, project a life-style different from the image of their parents,
from the earlier generations. They have become ?conscientious people
compromising with two cultures?. Compared to the first generation of Turks,
which existed almost exclusively as untrained manual workers, the generation of
today present a more promising picture:
It emerges that the Turks are represented in nearly all middle layers of
the social pyramid. Turkish society has considerably established itself
heterogeneously from employees to employer, from police officers to lawyers,
from doctors to MPs, in the German society.
However, the reciprocal influences on
cultural identities leading to some degree of bicultural identity, is a rather
recent concept in the whole community (Ward 2006). Despite these role models,
the question remains wide open: To what extent is the host community ready to
see itself as a multi-cultural, unbiased, multi-ethnic society?
Future studies on the acculturation of Turks living in
Germany should distinguish several spheres of acculturation: political,
economic, social, family and religion. Furthermore, extensive research should
be carried out to assess the ways in which cultural factors contribute both to
resilience, and to an increased vulnerability to psychiatric problems.
|
| REFERENCES
|
Beiser MN, Hou F (2006) Ethnic identity, resettlement stress and depressive
affect among Southeast Asian refugees in Canada. Soc Sci Med, 63:137-50.
Berry JW (2003) Conceptual approaches to acculturation. In K. M. Chun, P. B.
Organista, & G. Marín (Eds.), Acculturation: Advances in theory, measurement and
applied research (pp. 17-37). Washington, D.C.: American Psychological Assoc.
Bhugra D (2006) Severe mental illness across cultures. Acta Psychiatr Scand
Suppl. (429):17-23.
Cleveland M, Laroche M (2007) Acculturation to the global consumer culture: Scale
development and research paradigm, J. Business Research, 60: 249-259.
Coronado GD, Thompson B, McLerran D ve ark. (2005) A short acculturation scale
for Mexican-American populations. Ethn Dis, 15:53-62.
Eksi A (2002) Siginmaci ve Göcmenlerde Psikopatoloji (Psychopathology in asylum
seekers and immigrants), Türk Psikoloji Dergisi, 13: 215-221.
Floyd WR (2003) Critical history of the acculturation psychology of assimilation,
separation, integration and marginalization, Rev Gen Psychol, 7: 3-37.
Gong L (2007) Ethnic identity and identification with the majority group:
Relations with national identity and self-esteem., Int J Intercultural
Rel, 31: 503-523.
Gül V, Öner E, Uyar K ve ark. (2008) Kultur und Ethnicität: Ihre Rolle bei der
Entstehung psychischer Störungen am Beispiel der Türkischen Gemeinschaft in
Deutschland. Psycho-Neuro, 34:97-99.
Gül V, Saglam H, Kolb S ve ark. (2008) Somatisierungsstörungen und psychische
Komorbidität, Diagnose und Therapie Optionen am Beispiel türkischer Patienten in
Deutschland. Psycho-Neuro, 34: 213-215.
Gün Z, Bayraktar F (2008) The Role of Migration on the Adjustment of Adolescents
in Turkey, Türk Psikiyatri Dergisi, 19: 167-176.
Hovey JD, Kim SE, Seligman LD ve ark. (2006) The influences of cultural values,
ethnic identity, and language use on the mental health of Korean American
college students. J Psychol, 140:499-511.
Ilkilic I (2002) Bioethical conflicts between Muslim patients and German
physicians and the principles of biomedical ethics. Med Law 21: 243-56.
Kosic A, Mannetti L, Sam, David L ve ark. (2006) Self-monitoring: A moderating
role between acculturation strategies and adaptation of immigrants. Int J
Intercultural Rel, 30: 141-157.
La Fromboise T, Coleman HL, Gerton J ve ark. (1993) Psychological impact of
biculturalism: evidence and theory. Psychol Bull, 114:395-412.
Lahti JJ, Liebkind K, Horenczyk G ve ark. (2003) The interactive nature of
acculturation: perceived discrimination, acculturation attitudes and stress
among young ethnic repatriates in Finland, Israel and Germany J Intern.
Intercultural Rel, 27:79-97.
Navas M, Rojas AJ, García M ve ark. (2007) Acculturation strategies and attitudes
according to the Relative Acculturation Extended Model (RAEM): The perspectives
of natives versus immigrants. Int J Intercultural Rel, 31:67-86.
Machleidt W, Calliess IT (2005) Transkulturelle Psychiatrie und
Migration?Psychische Erkrankungen aus ethnischer Sicht. Die Psychiatrie,
2:77-84.
Mann MA (2006) The formation and development of individual and ethnic identity:
insights from psychiatry and psychoanalytic theory. Am J Psychoanal, 66:211-224.
Migrationsbericht (2006) Migrationsbericht des Bundesamtes für Migration und
Flüchtlinge im Auftrag der Bundesregierung Bundesministerium des Inneren (Hrsg.
2007): Nürnberg.
Mossakowski KN (2003) Coping with perceived discrimination: does ethnic identity
protect mental health? J Health Soc Behav, 44:318-331.
Munir KM, Beardslee WR (2001) A developmental and psychobiologic framework for
understanding the role of culture in child and adolescent psychiatry. Child
Adoles Psych Clin N Am, 10: 667-677.
Murad SD, Joung IM, Verhulst FC ve ark. (2004) Determinants of self-reported
emotional and behavioural problems in Turkish immigrant adolescents aged 11-18.
Soc Psych Psych Epidemiol, 39:196-207.
Pette M, Pachaly J, David M ve ark. (2004) Turkish and German patients' recall of
diagnosis and therapy before and following informed consent. Ethn Health,
9:213-223.
Schmeling-Kludas C, Fröschlin R (2003) Inpatient psychosomatic rehabilitation for
Turkish migrants: what can be realized, what are the effects? Rehabilitation
(Stuttg), 42:363-370.
Shuang L (2007) Living with others: Mapping the routes to acculturation in a
multicultural society Int J Intercultural Rel, 31:761-778.
Swinscow TDV (1978) Statistics at Square Qne, reprint of the BMJ, published by
British Medical Association.
Uluşahin A, Başoğlu M, Paykel ES ve ark. (1994) A cross-cultural comparative
study of depressive Symptoms in British and Turkish clinical samples. Soc Psych
Epidemiol, 29:31-39.
Vamsi K, Koneru AG, Mamani W ve ark. (2007) Acculturation and mental health:
Current findings and recommendations for future research. Applied and Preventive
Psychology, 12:76-96.
Vedder P, Virta E (2005) Language, ethnic identity, and the adaptation of Turkish
immigrant youth in the Netherlands and Sweden. International Journal of
Intercultural Relations, 29:317-337.
Virta E, Sam DL, Westin C ve ark. (2004) Adolescents with Turkish background in
Norway and Sweden: a comparative study of their psychological adaptation
Scand J Psychol, 45:15-25.
Ward C, Kennedy A (1994) Acculturation strategies, psychological adjustment, and
sociocultural competence during cross-cultural transitions International Journal
of Intercultural Relations, 18; 329-343.
Ward C (2006) Acculturation, identity and adaptation in dual heritage adolescents
International Journal of Intercultural Relations, 30: 243-259.
Yagdiran O, Haasen C, Krausz M ve ark. (2001) Psychotic experiences in a
transcultural context - case report analysis on the importance of the second
language for the therapeutic process. Psychiatr Prax, 28:380-382.
Zielke-Nadkarni A (2003) The meaning of the family: lived experiences of Turkish
women immigrants in Germany. Nurs Sci Q, 16:169-173.
|
|